In 1897, two researchers watching telegraph operators learn Morse code noticed something odd. The trainees improved quickly, then stalled for weeks however hard they practised, then suddenly got better again. William Lowe Bryan and Noble Harter concluded the operators had taken hearing code letter by letter as far as it would go. The leap came when they started hearing whole words. Josh Cote has seen the same pattern in sales teams for over 25 years, and he believes most managers misread it. This article explains the three kinds of plateau, how to tell them apart and what to do about each.
The straight line nobody actually walks
Ask most people to sketch their growth plan and they’ll draw a straight line pointing up and to the right. More effort, more results, every month a little better than the last. Promotion is just the next step on the same slope.
That isn’t how it happens. Growth moves in stages: a slow start, a period where things begin to click, then a flatter stretch before the next challenge arrives. A new role or a bigger target usually starts the cycle again, which is why so many people feel worse at their job just after they’ve been promoted.
The straight line isn’t harmless. If you expect it, every plateau looks like failure. Managers lose patience with people who are about to improve, and people lose faith in themselves at exactly the wrong moment.
Three phases of getting good at something
It helps to know what each stage feels like from the inside.
In early learning, the tasks are unfamiliar, mistakes are frequent and the person needs a lot of guidance. Visible progress is slow. A new salesperson in this phase is working hard and seeing little return, and that’s often when they quietly start wondering whether they’re cut out for it.
In rapid improvement, things connect. They recognise patterns, handle the common objections without thinking and apply what they’ve learned more consistently. This is the phase everyone enjoys.
In consolidation, performance becomes reliable, but the gains get smaller because their current methods are reaching their limits. They can do the job well. The honest question becomes: what comes next?
These phases are a coaching model, not a timetable. People move through them at different speeds, and nobody follows them perfectly in order.
Learning, coasting or stuck: what a flat result can’t tell you
Two people can post identical numbers for three months for completely different reasons. Josh Cote finds it useful to sort a plateau into one of three types before doing anything about it.
Learning. The person is building capability that hasn’t shown up in results yet, or consolidating a skill through repetition. A new team leader spending more time coaching may sell less personally for a while before the team improves. This plateau needs patience and support.
Coasting. The person has reached consolidation and made it a resting place. They’re good enough, comfortable, and no longer stretching. This plateau needs a new challenge and an honest conversation about ambition, not more training.
Stuck. The person is working hard, but their method has hit its limit, just like the telegraph operators hearing one letter at a time. Or something is in the way: unclear expectations, a broken process, or weak coaching. This plateau needs a change of approach, and sometimes the change needed is the manager’s, not the salesperson’s.
Treat a learner like a coaster and you knock their confidence just before they improve. Treat someone stuck like a learner and you’ll wait months for progress that was never coming. The diagnosis matters more than the response.
The question to ask before you judge anyone
The most useful question Josh puts to managers is this: what evidence shows this person is becoming more capable, even if the final result hasn’t moved yet?
For a salesperson, that evidence might be better discovery questions, longer conversations with decision-makers, or fewer deals lost at the same stage. For a team leader, it’s stronger coaching, fewer repeated mistakes, better retention and more people performing without them stepping in.
If you can find that evidence, you’re probably looking at a learning plateau. If the activity is steady but nothing underneath is changing, you’re more likely looking at someone coasting. If the effort is clearly there but the same problems keep coming back, they’re probably stuck.
This is where most sales teams fall down. Managers rarely see enough of the work to answer the question. They see the dashboard, not the calls. That’s one reason Josh describes most teams as undercoached rather than undertrained: the information needed to read a plateau only comes from watching people work.
Patience with a deadline
There’s a risk in all of this. “Growth isn’t linear” can turn into an excuse for anything. Non-linear growth is real, but it doesn’t justify indefinite underperformance.
The answer is patience with a deadline. In practice that looks like four steps:
- Define success. Agree the results and the behaviours expected, in writing, so both sides know what “improving” means.
- Name the gap. Be specific about what the person needs to learn or change. “Be more confident” isn’t a gap. “Hasn’t yet asked for the decision on a first call” is.
- Support it properly. Coaching, practice, observation and feedback while it’s still useful, not at the quarterly review.
- Review the evidence on a set date. Look at capability and results together. If neither has moved by then, it’s time for a different conversation.
The habit that makes this work is a short, regular review at the same time each week. Consistency matters more than length. A fifteen-minute conversation that happens every week will tell you more about a plateau than a two-hour appraisal twice a year.
One more thing worth saying to your team directly. When someone takes on a bigger role, they’ll often feel less comfortable before they become more capable. That’s normal. The goal isn’t to feel confident quickly. It’s to build confidence on the back of repeatable performance, so it lasts.
A plateau is a question, not a verdict.
Frequently asked questions
What is a learning plateau?
A learning plateau is a period where performance stops improving despite continued effort. The idea goes back to Bryan and Harter’s 1897 study of telegraph operators, who improved quickly, levelled off for long stretches, then improved again. In business, plateaus often appear after a new role, a bigger target or once someone has mastered their current methods.
How can you tell if an employee is learning, coasting or stuck?
Look for evidence of growing capability underneath the results. If skills and behaviours are improving but results haven’t caught up, they’re probably learning. If activity is steady but nothing is changing, they may be coasting, and if effort is high but the same problems keep recurring, they’re likely stuck and need a different approach.
Is a performance plateau a sign of a poor hire?
Not usually. Plateaus are a normal part of how people develop, especially after a promotion or a change in role. A plateau only becomes a concern when there’s no evidence of growing capability and nothing has changed after a clear, agreed review period.
How long should a manager wait before acting on a plateau?
There’s no fixed timeframe, because people progress at different speeds. The better approach is to agree success measures, name the specific gap, provide coaching and set a review date in advance. If neither capability nor results have moved by that date, it’s time for a more direct conversation.
How can EAW Consulting help leaders get their teams past a plateau?
EAW Consulting works with business owners and sales leaders to diagnose why performance has stalled and to put the coaching, standards and review routines in place to move it again. Josh Cote personally leads every engagement, drawing on over 25 years of building and coaching sales teams in the UK and US. Get in touch through eawconsulting.co.uk to talk about your team.



